C&C my render

[Plaid]

I want to make a sig with Soniko but i could not find any renders of her so i decided to do it myself. I followed a youtube guide and This (http://i42.tinypic.com/aypsgw.png) is how it turned out .

But i ended up with two results so here (http://i39.tinypic.com/2148o0l.png) is the other one.

Tell me which one is the best. Or is both of them crap?
Thx for C&C in advance! :)

[+dd. KRS25]

That is one of the best renders I've seen! You've done a really nice job on that, great work! Can't see any obvious flaws.. its really good!

[Plaid]

Well, i noticed that i missed some spots :P i am going to edit the post in a second.
Btw, thanks for the compliments :D

[oblueknighto]

You do realize where Soniko is a character from ... you know right? Is that the reason you couldn't find any renders of her?

[Plaid]

Shes a mascot for a company called nitro+. I wont say what the company does. But i guess you figured out :P But i know where you are getting at blueknight >< i know... And in guess thats why there where no renders of her.
But i like the character, and a lot of people do. You can find pictures of her everywhere. Like the anime torrent site nyaatorrents.org use a picture of her to represent music filled torrents.

[oblueknighto]

*COUGH* Well since you know, there are many renders of her, but they are not ... appropriate for use in regular signatures. I guess that's all there is to it.

[Plaid]

I will only use appropriate pictures of her on the site ofc :P Dont have any intention of using the others. But i want to know what you think of my render blue kinght! Thats why i made the thread.
which is best? nr 1 or nr 2?
need to know, want to keep a certain style on my renders.

[oblueknighto]

That is a very hard question because some parts I like v1 where other I like v2, probably v1 overall but I can't tell because the way you did the cutting, I don't know.